Australian Asthma Handbook

Australian Asthma Handbook

The National Guidelines for Health Professionals

Diagnosis / Children 1-5 years

Diagnosing asthma in children 1–5 years

Diagnosis of asthma in children 1–5 years Figure
Signs and symptoms that suggest an alternative diagnosis in children Table
Features suggesting higher or lower probability of asthma in children Table
Recommendation

Take a focused history.


Ask about:

  • current signs and symptoms (wheeze, difficult breathing, feeling of tightness in chest, cough)
  • whether signs/symptoms are accompanied by increased work of breathing, tracheal tug, or subcostal recession (describe these to parents)
  • pattern of signs/symptoms (how often in daytime, whether symptoms cause nighttime waking)
  • whether wheezing or other signs/symptoms occur only when child has a viral cold, or are unrelated to colds
  • what else provokes signs/symptoms (e.g. playing or laughing, cold dry air, allergens, exposure to smoking/vaping)
  • whether child is generally alert and active
  • home environment (pets, indoor air pollution, carpet)
  • exposure to smoking/vaping
  • history of allergies (including atopic dermatitis, allergic rhinitis, food allergies)
  • history of respiratory and other infections
  • neonatal history (premature birth, difficulty breathing soon after birth, admission to a neonatal ICU)
  • respiratory health in first year of life (e.g. hospitalisation due to a lower respiratory tract infection, bronchiolitis)
  • family history of asthma and allergies.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

History features that suggest an alternative diagnosis, including red flags, are listed in Table: Signs and symptoms that suggest an alternative diagnosis in children

The probability of asthma is higher if signs and symptoms are frequent, triggered by common asthma triggers, sometimes occur in the absence of upper respiratory tract infections, or there is a family history of allergies or asthma (Table: Features suggesting higher or lower probability of asthma in children)

Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne’s What is asthma? video for parents explaining how to identify wheeze and other signs

Recommendation

Perform a general physical examination including vital signs and chest auscultation.


Include the following:

  • Record vital signs.
  • Observe breathing.
  • Auscultate chest.
  • Measure height and weight compared with normal range for age (and track growth history within child’s percentile band).
  • Inspection of chest for deformity
  • Inspect upper airway for signs of allergic rhinitis (e.g. swollen turbinates, transverse nasal crease, mouth breathing, darkness and swelling under eyes caused by sinus congestion) or polyps.
  • Inspect fingers for clubbing
  • Inspect skin for signs of atopic dermatitis.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

Physical examination findings that suggest an alternative diagnosis, including red flags, are listed in Table: Signs and symptoms that suggest an alternative diagnosis in children. 

Usually no abnormalities are detected on physical examination of a child with asthma. 

Objective confirmation of wheeze is useful. Check medical records for wheeze confirmed by a health professional. If wheeze is not detectable during the consultation, ask parents to record an episode (video or audio).

The chest may be silent in severe acute asthma. 

Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne’s What is asthma? video for parents explaining how to identify wheeze and other signs

Recommendation

Assess clinical response to salbutamol.


Clinical response can be verified by either of the following:

  • resolution of signs within minutes after administration of salbutamol via pMDI and spacer (with facemask, if needed) by parents or in primary care
  • history of documented response to salbutamol administered in an emergency department during an acute respiratory episode (e.g. partial resolution within minutes).

Consensus recommendation

If symptoms rapidly and consistently resolve after administration of inhaled salbutamol, this supports the diagnosis of asthma.

Recommendation

Consider a treatment trial of maintenance low-dose ICS plus inhaled salbutamol as needed for 8–12 weeks.


A treatment trial with ICS is indicated for children with any of the following:

  • frequent symptoms (daytime symptoms more than twice per week or night-time symptoms more than twice per month)
  • symptoms restricting activity or sleep (when child does not have an acute wheezing episode or respiratory viral infection)
  • history of recurrent acute wheezing episodes (more than 4 per year)
  • more than one acute wheezing episode within the past 12 months managed in the emergency department or treated with systemic corticosteroids
  • previous PICU admission for an acute salbutamol-responsive wheezing episode.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

Resolution or significant improvement of signs and symptoms during a treatment trial with low-dose ICS supports the diagnosis of asthma.

If symptoms do not resolve during a trial of low-dose maintenance ICS, check inhaler technique, adherence, triggers, reconsider the diagnosis, and consider specialist referral.

The treatment trial should be performed at a time when the child is likely to be exposed to usual triggers.

A treatment trial is unlikely to provide evidence useful for supporting or ruling out the diagnosis if it is performed under conditions in which the child typically does not experience symptoms or have exacerbations (e.g. outside the cold and influenza season or when there is no relevant allergen exposure).

Recommendation

Consider specialist referral if the diagnosis is unclear but the child has clinically significant respiratory signs and symptoms.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

Recommendation

Do not diagnose asthma in a child younger than 12 months.


If a child younger than 12 months shows persistent wheezing, refer to a specialist.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

In children younger than 12 months, episodes of acute wheeze with increased work of breathing are usually caused by bronchiolitis, which is most commonly due to respiratory syncytial virus.[Dalziel 2022]

Transient early wheeze (noisy breathing in infants younger than 12 months who are otherwise well and thriving) should not be diagnosed as asthma or treated with bronchodilators.

Dalziel SR, Haskell L, O'Brien S, et al. Bronchiolitis. Lancet 2022; 400: 392-406.

Suitable specialists for referral include paediatricians, paediatric respiratory physicians, and allergists.

Consideration

If wheeze is the predominant sign reported, verify and ascertain clinical significance.


Confirm that more than one episode has occurred.

Confirm that the sound reported by the child or parents is actually wheeze – ask parents to video/audio record the wheeze to verify.

Determine whether wheeze only occurs during viral respiratory tract infections, or also occurs during physical activity and at other times.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

Careful questioning or recordings may be necessary to correctly identify respiratory signs. Parents may not be able to recognise wheezing, stridor, snoring or normal breathing. [Fernandes 2011]

Asthma is more likely if wheezing occurs during play or exposure to allergens.

Fernandes RM, Robalo B, Calado C, et al. The multiple meanings of "wheezing": a questionnaire survey in Portuguese for parents and health professionals. BMC Pediatr 2011; 11: 112.

Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne’s What is asthma? video for parents explaining how to identify wheeze and other signs

Consideration

If cough is the predominant sign reported, investigate and manage according to current Australian guidelines.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

Coughing is normal in preschool children in the context of frequent respiratory infections. Isolated dry cough in an otherwise well preschool child is rarely due to a specific diagnosis.[Bush 2023] Intermittent wet cough during viral colds is normal; preschool children typically have many colds per year with symptoms lasting up to 3 weeks each time.[Bush 2023]

Asthma is among the most common causes of chronic cough in children with no abnormality detected on physical examination, chest radiography or spirometry.[Marchant 2024] Asthma may cause episodic cough that is associated with expiratory wheeze and/or exertional dyspnoea.[Marchant 2024] 

In children, cough due to asthma typically resolves within one month of treatment with ICS.[Marchant 2024] ICS treatment is not indicated unless there are specific features to suggest asthma.[Marchant 2024]

Chronic cough in the absence of other symptoms/signs is rarely due to asthma.[Marchant 2024] The diagnosis of preschool asthma should not be made unless the child also has breathlessness, chest tightness, or wheeze.[Bush 2023] Other causes of chronic cough in children include respiratory tract infections, airway anomaly, aspiration, rhinitis/rhinosinusitis and somatic syndrome.[Marchant 2024, Kantar 2022] Wet cough persisting beyond 3 weeks suggests protracted bacterial bronchitis requiring antibiotic treatment. Specialist referral should be considered for children with multiple episodes of prolonged wet cough or failure to resolved with antibiotic treatment.[Marchant 2024]

Bush A. Basic clinical management of preschool wheeze. Pediatr Allergy Immunol 2023; 34: e13988.

Kantar A, Marchant JM, Song WJ, et al. History taking as a diagnostic tool in children with chronic cough. Front Pediatr 2022; 10: 850912.

Marchant JM, Chang AB, Kennedy E, et al. Cough in Children and Adults: Diagnosis, Assessment and Management (CICADA). Summary of an updated position statement on chronic cough in Australia. Med J Aust 2024; 220: 35-45.

Consideration

FeNO testing can be considered (if available) for children ≥ 4 years old.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

FeNO ≥25 ppb supports the diagnosis of asthma in a child with and signs and symptoms strongly suggesting asthma.

In children and adolescents aged ≥5 years, a FeNO level > 24 ppb has a reported sensitivity of 0.50 and specificity of 0.91 for the diagnosis of asthma.[BTS-NICE-SIGN 2024]

Normal FeNO level does not rule out asthma.

Högman M, Bowerman C, Chavez L, et al; Global Lung Function Initiative FENO Task Force. ERS technical standard: Global Lung Function Initiative reference values for exhaled nitric oxide fraction (FENO50 ). Eur Respir J 2024; 63: 2300370.

The FeNO test is available in accredited respiratory function laboratories. Age restrictions differ between laboratories.

Normal reference ranges for FeNO vary between measuring devices and testing protocols.[Högman 2024]

The test can generally be performed correctly by children 4 years and older. 

FeNO is elevated in the presence of active type-2 inflammation of the airway associated with asthma. It is also elevated in some other inflammatory conditions (e.g. allergic rhinitis).

FeNO is suppressed by ICS and systemic corticosteroids.

The FeNO test is more useful for ruling in a diagnosis of asthma than ruling it out. A normal FeNO level does not rule out asthma.

More information on tests of airway inflammation

Consideration

If allergic triggers are suspected, arrange allergy testing for common aeroallergens to inform management.


Arrange either skin-prick testing or serum test for allergen-specific IgE.

Recommendation type: Consensus recommendation

Allergy testing is not recommended as a standalone diagnostic test for asthma, due to its low specificity.[ERS 2021] However, allergy testing at the time of diagnosis is useful to inform management because most children with asthma have allergies, which may affect asthma control.

The presence of allergies in preschool children with asthma-like signs and symptoms is also associated with a higher probability that the child will have asthma at primary school age.[Kothalawala 2020]

The most common aeroallergens causing asthma or allergic rhinitis are dust mites, pollens (most often grass pollen, less often other wind-borne pollens from trees and weeds), animal epithelia, and moulds.[ASCIA 2020]

The history may help identify relevant aeroallergens for testing.

Either skin-prick testing or allergen-specific IgE antibody testing can be used to identify clinically relevant aeroallergens.[ASCIA 2024, ASCIA 2020]

ASCIA. Laboratory investigation for allergic diseases. Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy, 2020. 

ASCIA. Skin prick testing guide for diagnosis of allergic diseases. Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy, 2024.

Gaillard EA, Kuehni CE, Turner S, et al. European Respiratory Society clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis of asthma in children aged 5-16 years. Eur Respir J 2021; 58: 2004173.

Kothalawala DM, Kadalayil L, Weiss VBN, et al. Prediction models for childhood asthma: A systematic review. Pediatr Allergy Immunol 2020; 31: 616-627.

Practice point

Common non-asthma causes of respiratory symptoms in preschool children include viral-induced wheeze, recurrent viral colds, and persistent bacterial bronchitis. Less common causes to consider include pertussis and foreign body inhalation.

Practice point

If the child has previously been treated for possible asthma, ask about frequency of reliever use, whether the child has received oral corticosteroids, ED visits, hospital admission, ICU admission, and any previous maintenance treatment for asthma.

Practice point

Treatment trials for the purpose of confirming the diagnosis should be performed at a time when the child is likely to be exposed to usual triggers. A treatment trial is unlikely to provide evidence useful for supporting or ruling out the diagnosis if it is performed under conditions in which the child typically does not experience symptoms or have exacerbations (e.g. outside the cold and influenza season or when there is no relevant allergen exposure).

Practice point

Oscillometry is an emerging test for lung function in children, but is not commonly used in clinical practice.

Related content